DD letting Snape abuse students (Re: Harry learning from Snape)

[phoenixgod2000]

No: HPFGUIDX 114479


> Dzeytoun:
> Exactly.  The question is NOT allowing different opinions.  The 
> question is about sitting back while a bully emotionally abuses 
> students.  That is UTTERLY indefensible and smacks of 
> spinelessness.


I could not have put it anymore succinctly than that. Sometimes I do 
not understand the lengths that people go to in order to forgive 
Snape for his actions.  In many ways Snape is every bit the villain 
of the HP books that Voldemort is, he just happens to be on the same 
side as Harry.  And Dumbledore remains almost totally understandable 
when it comes to Snape.  I even have trouble writing him sometimes 
because I don't get his motivations.  Someone as wise and 
knowledgable as DD should not allow what Snape does to occur.  He 
just shouldn't. When that happens, I read Daddy's Favorite and for a 
little while I like Dumbledore again.

Good job on that fic by the way.

"phoenixgod2000"