Snape--Abusive?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 114699


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "pippin_999" <foxmoth at q...> 
wrote:

snip.

> It wouldn't be very satisfying to me if Harry 
> was noble enough to forgo vengeance on  Pettigrew  for killing 
> his parents and then took out his wrath on Snape for insulting 
> them. To paraphrase something Ron never said, he'd really 
> need to rethink his priorities.
> 



Alla:

Temporarily, Pippin, yes. Permanently - please, please, No.

Personally I see two alternative plot developments, which will be 
satisfying for me (I will aceept anything JKR writes, of course, 
but...:))

I want to see Snape change as I said many times. If we will see ANY 
changes, GREAT.

If he does not change, yes, of course, I would rather Harry not to 
spend his energy dealing with Snape's behaviour, untill he is done 
with Voldemort.

Afterwards, I REALLY want to see Harry to bring Snape down. No, I 
don't want him to kill Snape, of course not. But I want Harry to 
show Snape that he IS a better person in a way where Snape's pride 
will be hurt.

The best scenarion under such circumstanmces TO ME would be Harry 
saving Snape life and making Snape realise that he owes life debt to 
Potter all over again.