New thoughts on Sirius

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 114757


> Jen: Ah, you all are probably right--I'll keep the faith ;). Like 
> you said Alla, JKR didn't say anything we haven't discussed 
> endlessly on the list. But, she also pretty much closed the door 
on 
> any new significant backstory that we're not aware of yet--what 
you 
> see is what you get. Sirius *is* exactly as we've discussed him on-
> list and there's no more mystery to uncover. Not to say he won't 
re-
> appear in some form, but he most likely won't be significant for 
the 
> backstory, just the current one.
> 
> Sometimes I think I'd do better *not* to read the comments on 
JKR's 
> website. As more and more truths are revealed, I find myself 
missing 
> the time when everything was mysterious and therefore open to 
> speculation. And I could hold on to my own beliefs about what JKR 
is 
> trying to say, rather than finding out the truth ;).
> 
> Jen, glad JKR continues to comment on Lupin in positive ways.



Alla:

I do know what you mean, Jen. On one hand I LIKE new information, on 
the other I want some mystery lfet.

You are right, we may not get any new information about Sirius 
characterisation, but I think we already got lucky, because OOP 
revealed A LOT of depth about Sirius,a lot of the reasons behind his 
motives.

I am not sure I agree that we will not get any new backstory. She 
PROMISED us more about the reasons for the mutual hatred between 
Sirius and Snape  and she better live up to it. :o)

I am VERY interested in Prank backstory :o) and I think we will 
learn it eventually.


Yes, after today I am finally saying good buy to ESE!Lupin in my 
mind.

Remus is one of her favourite characters, she would LOVE to meet 
him, she thinks that he is more MATURE that Sirius, whom she likes 
even though she does not like some of his traits.

Sorry, Pippin. :)