Quesiton for Snapeophiles and -phobes RE Dumbledore, Snape, and Harry

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 114822


> Alla:
> 
> As you stated correctly, HEARD is the key word. Someone else 
is  telling about the murders was not very convincing to me.
> 
> The only scene in HP series , where I was convinced of 
Voldemort  evil  because of the way he acted was Graveyard 
scene in GoF.
> 
> That was VERY GOOD writing. Anything else, sorry, not scared.

Pippin:

Isn't that one of the problems when dealing with real evil?How 
many people have died, in Oswiecm and the gulags and 
Rwanda, because evil is beyond our imagination?  I think it's very 
realistic that Harry's problems with Snape seem more real than 
the menace of Voldemort, or sad to say, Darfur.

 And, sorry, eyewitnesses to murder are seldom available, not if 
the murderer has anything to say about it. 

>  
> Alla:
> I would agree, if you change "occasionally abusive" to 
"constantly  abusive" :o).<

Constantly? No. We don't witness all  the potions classes or 
even all the occlumency lessons -- only the ones where Snape 
is particularly harsh. 

Pippin