Judgments about Snape-lovers

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 114917


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "M.Clifford" <Aisbelmon at h...> 
wrote:

snip.

>> Correct me if I am wrong but in the debate of James v Snape in 
the 
> penseive "James is/was Evil?" debate the underdog would be the 
one  
> likely to lose which would be James, yes? So therefore the bevvy 
of 
> Snape supporters contributing would be *against* the underdog in 
> that particular debate. 
> 
> And in the Harry v Snape debate we are talking 11 yr old boy fresh 
> from abusive home gets picked on by a grown man emotionally and 
> those who say the *boy* should be expected to behave better are 
the 
> ones rooting for the *underdog*? Matt, _that's_ absurd , that one 
> please remove it from the list.


Alla:

As Snape's partial lover I must partially disagree with you , Valky 
and you know it is always very painful for me to do. :o).

Yes, in Snape/Harry context I find it very funny to hear that Snape 
fans roote for for underdog, because to me Harry is very, very, very 
underdog in this couple.


But in Snape/James debate it is very hard for me to determine who 
the underdog is. In Pencieve scene in particular James does not look 
like an underdog to me.