Snape--Abusive?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 114973


> SSSusan:
> Still, I would argue that there *is* at least one way in which 
> Snape's methods have harmed or hurt Harry.  By this I am thinking 
> of "harmed" or "hurt" less in the sense of emotional distress and 
> more in the sense of HINDERING his learning.  
snip.

 Snape, I 
> believe, *is* privy to that, and one of his primary concerns 
should 
> be to see that Harry is learning, even if it means he has to bite 
his 
> tongue on occasion.



Alla:

Oh, yes. I don't know when if ever I will be ready to forgive Snape 
for the Occlumency disaster. I am of the firm opinion that Harry 
would have done MUCH better with the teacher he trusted. Oh, well, 
we will never know, huh.

For a while I was of the opinion that Snape does not value Harry's 
life, not just his ability to learn Occlumency.

Which to me is extreme carelesness, boderline stupidity.