The Black Bloodline
macfotuk at yahoo.com
macfotuk at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 7 00:51:18 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 115025
usual apolgies if this is 'me too' or stepping on the toes of
earlier posts I haven't seen.
Grimmauld Place belongs to the 'Blacks' and the tapestry is about
the noble and ancient house of Blacks. Yet in the chapter of the
same title (OoP, Ch.6) Kreacher clearly owes his allegiance much
more to Sirius' mother than his father and her portrait in an
earlier chapter screams of half breeds and, above all, 'how dare you
befoul the house of my fathers -'.
SURELY, it isn't HER father's house (meaning either her actual
father or her forefathers) since she (presumably) gained the name
Black by marriage? Here are some equally peculiar possibilities;
-Sirius' mother didn't change her name upon marriage.
-It was such a close intermarriage that both were called Hubby and
Wife-to-be were Blacks already and she insisted on living in 'her'
home.
- She made HIM adopt HER name.
-She didn't marry Sirius' father (unthinkable I think in WW)
-She has so embraced her 'new' (as opposed to birth) family to the
point of feeling 'descended' - through her children at least
- A Flint (unlikely)
Another of those things that make you go hmmmmmmmm
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive