OotP Harry not a prefect & his Inner Voice
totorivers
tombadgerlock at freesurf.fr
Thu Oct 7 20:58:41 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 115147
> Del replies :
> Actually, if you look closely, you'll realise that making Ron and
> Hermione Prefects does not seem to have brought anything to the
> story. You say we learned Hermione has a backbone, but let's be
> honest, we'd known that for a *long* time (all the way back to
> PS/SS in fact). As for Ron, as you point out, becoming a Prefect
> doesn't seem to have had any effect on him. It seems all of it was
> almost *useless*.
Toto:
I'll beg to differ there. I think that if Ron hadn't been made
prefect, he may have been harder on Harry and so on: Ron's prefect
badge first, and then being on the quidditch team, have helped him
accept himself and learn not to "steal" Harry's way of doing things.
It helped him mature (not that I like what he is maturing into that
much).
Another point: To have made them prefect have shown that they have
different methods, and do *not* work well as a team.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive