CHAPTER DISCUSSION: Chapter 28, Snape's worst memory

[frugalarugala]

No: HPFGUIDX 115151


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Bex" <hubbarrk at r...> wrote:
Yb wrote: 
> If it was DD's Pensieve (I doubt there are many around, 
> and Harry thought it was DD's), heck, even if DD /knew/ 
> Snape was using a Pensieve, given Harry's nature, surely 
> DD would warn Snape that Harry knew how to work it. Snape
> /had/ to have known that Harry would be curious. This
> scene is actually reeking of setup here!
>
> Meri's right, there are really only a few options:
> a) Harry had to see that memory for some reason
> b) Snape needed an excuse to not teach Harry anymore.
> c) Something I can't think of.
> 

For 'c', how about... Lord Voldemort is privy to the contents of 
Harry's brain. If it was a setup, maybe it wasn't to show Harry the 
memory, but just to feed it to Voldemort through him, mudblood 
comment and all, to help get Snape back in as a spy?  

I mean, if you look at things from a tactical POV, Harry is now 
officially a HUGE security risk! They have to assume everything 
Harry's figured out, Voldemort *might* know. 

--Frugalarugala, catering to all your conspiracy theory needs