Harry & Seamus (Was: Harry not a Prefect & his Inner Voice)

[mrs_sonofgib]

No: HPFGUIDX 115172


> 
> > Del wrote:
>  In fact, Harry's interaction with those boys is a quite clear
> > illustration of what you say : they are all in the same class, 
they
> > sleep in the same dorm, but we don't see that Harry knows either 
of
> > them very well beyond that (and vice versa). > 

Finwitch now:
> 
> Actually, I'm not at all annoyed with Harry. They *do* share a 
dorm.
> They *do* share classes. This means that
> 
> 1) Seamus must have seen enough to know that Harry is NOT insane, 
or
> at least enough for reasonable doubt, and never mind what his 
mother
> who has never so much as met Harry says based on hearsay of others 
who
> don't know Harry either.
> 
Tina adds:
Not that it detracts from your point but (as I'm sure you'll 
remember) Mrs. Finnegan did meet Harry (briefly to be sure) at the 
QWC.
BTW, I totally agree that Seamus owed Harry *at least* the chance to 
defend himself before Seamus made up his mind