Cataloging Snape's Behavior,

stbjohn2 stbjohn2 at yahoo.com
Sat Oct 9 01:41:44 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 115261


> Neri wrote:
> Why does Snape prefer the cold dungeon so much that he made it his
> office? It might be due to a mechanistic reason (like "Snape is a
> vampire") but I tend to think it is a metaphor. IMHO JKR tells us 
> that Snape is a cold person. Unnaturally cold, actually, so much so 
> that there is something suspicious about his humanity.


Sandy here:
I've always wondered if Snape didn't end up with the dungeon office 
as a form of self-inflicted punishment for whatever deeds he might 
have done as a DE. (nothing I can prove, just an occasional thought, 
since he seems the kind of brooding personality that might do that).
Another possibility would be that DD assigned him the dungeon digs as 
a gentle reminder that he *could* be in Azkaban, instead, but that is 
out of character for DD.













More information about the HPforGrownups archive