Now, I'm not a herpetologist, *but*...

nkafkafi nkafkafi at yahoo.com
Sun Oct 10 20:07:44 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 115345



> > Neri:
> > Just one (not zoological) comment: there is actually no canon that
> > Nagini can see through invisibility cloaks, with IR or without it.
> > When Harry sees Arthur through the snake's eyes we are told:
> >  
> > (OotP, Ch. 21)
> > "But the man was stirring . . . a silver cloak fell from his legs as
> > he jumped to his feet"
> 
> bboyminn:
> 
> Not quite, you missed one very important part. 
> 
> -Ootp AM ed, HB, pg 462-
> "...It was dark, yet he could see objects around him shimmering in
> strange, vibrant colors. ..."
> 
> That implies Infra-red seeing to me.
> 

Neri again:
Just to clarify my meaning, I didn't say Nagini doesn't see in infra
red. It certainly seems likely from the description (although the last
time I looked into a military IR device the view was in black and
white, but admittedly it was more than ten years ago). We also don't
know if invisibility cloaks block IR frequencies or not. All I say is
that we don't have canon here that Nagini sees through Invisibility
cloaks. Had JKR wanted to imply it she would have written the cloak
falling from Arthur's body, not his legs. 








More information about the HPforGrownups archive