[HPforGrownups] Re: Two-way mirror at GH

[AnitaKH]

No: HPFGUIDX 115468





--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, AnitaKH <anita_hillin at y...> 
wrote:
I propose that the Two-way Mirror had some role in revealing the events of Godric's Hollow on that Fateful Night.

mhbobbin:

Not half-baked at all. I like it.  I'm willing to consider the Floo Network though the two way mirror is better. Even better than Portraits. Further to this--what if the man that Harry hears yelling to Lily to take Harry and run--wasn't James but someone that James /Lily was talking to through one of these methods. (or even in the Portrait although Portraits seem to take orders rather than give 
them.) 

Lupin reacts so strangely (PoA) when Harry mentions that he thinks he  heard his father in the Dementor flashback that I doubt the man Harry hears is James. So what if that unknown man was, in effect, "on the phone" with Godric Hollow when the attack occurs. It would be consistent with some contemporary murder mysteries. (I can't think of one now.)

[snips]

Thanks for thinking this idea isn't totally off the wall.  My MO is to come up with an idea and then let you bright folks shoot it down or flesh it out.  

I really like your idea that the voice Harry hears may be emanating from the mirror, and since we haven't been shown exactly how it works, we can speculate all we like.  We're all deeply suspicious that the "James" voice isn't James at all, so this would answer that rather neatly.

 

akh, who ought to be heading to church right now.  Bye!




		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
vote.yahoo.com - Register online to vote today!

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]