Snape:second chance?

[legobaty29]

No: HPFGUIDX 115604



> Lisa Marie:
> Hi, vivek.  I'm also a new member! I have a possible answer to your 
> question, however unsatisfactory it may be: there is no real "first 
> chance," and it's just a figure of speech.  I assume that, in the 
> WW, everyone starts out with the "chance" to be good and only 
> joining LV would require the giving of a "second chance." I think 
> that Snape squandered his "first chance" when he joined the DE in 
> the first place. <snip>


Hello Vivek and Lisa Marie.  I am also a new user and I agree with
Lisa Marie that Snape's first chance was used up when he joined the 
Death Eaters. I know that Dumbledore trusts him, but I wonder whether 
he will ever be tempted to re-join Voldemort?  It has been suggested 
that he won't (I think he touched on the subject during a conversation 
with Karkaroff?) but the mark on his arm becomes stronger when Voldemort
is around, and I am thinking a) once you've been a Death Eater you can 
never get rid of the mark or b) Snape has never got rid of the mark 
because there's a thin chance he still has an allegiance there.

What do you think?


"legobaty29"