Snape--Abusive?

[vekkel1]

No: HPFGUIDX 115625


Carol:
> Del is right, based on Snape's own remarks. But Occlumency is a rare
> skill and Snape is not only a "superb Occlumens," he is the only one
> available. If Lupin or McGonagall could have done it, Dumbledore would
> have asked them to. (The werewolf business would have made it
> difficult for Upin to teach Harry, but arrangements could have been
> made--the Shrieking Shack, for example.) But Snape was the only
> available candidate.


I can think of one person who could have probably done a much better
job than Snape. He has a long white beard and was a former teacher,
headmaster as well, would even probably work better with Harry than
Snape, and I'm sure has much more experience.

Vekkel