Krum as DADA (was Aberforth as DADA teacher/Dumbledore Muggleborn?)

quigonginger quigonginger at yahoo.com
Sat Oct 16 15:28:46 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 115701


> Barb:
> 
> This is my first post, so be gentle! 
> 
> I think Krum as DADA has potential for comedy between Ron and 
> Hermione, (I am a R/H shipper), but I don't think he's qualified. 
In 
> OotP (page 331)..."Yeah? What did Vicky say?" "Ho, Ho," said 
> Hermione in a bored voice, "He said Harry knew how to do stuff even 
> he didn't, and he was in the final year at Durmstrang."
> 
> Now granted, Harry is exceptional, but still, it sounds like 
> Durmstrang put more of an emphasis on learning the Dark Arts 
> themselves, not Defense against them. Personally, my current theory 
> is to have Snape go to DADA, since that is the only way I can see 
> Harry continue in Potions (and it would give Snape a chance to see 
> Harry and Neville excel in something!) Wow, that was a long 
sentence!
> 
> -Barb

Ginger:
Welcome to the list, Barb.  
I was just musing about Krum, actually.  I thought as you did that 
the R/H factor would be interesting and comic.  I'm a R/H shipper too.

The other part that I thought would be interesting was the 
Durmstrang/Slytherin connection.  Draco and Co. would be familiar 
with him as the Durmstrang crew took their meals at the Slytherin 
table for almost a year during the tournament.  I can just see 
them:  "Come on, Prof. Krum, show us some REAL Dark stuff, like you 
learned at your school!"  Unfortunately, we wouldn't get to see it, 
since Gryffindor and Slytherin don't have DADA together.  
Hmm...unless...with smaller post-OWL classes, maybe they combine the 
two.  Worth a thought.  

You are right that he doesn't have the experience, but DD is getting 
desperate to fill the position.  It was more of an off-hand thought 
than a full theory.  But it could be fun.  Too bad it makes Krum 
potential coffin-filler.

Ginger, needing to get to her housework.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive