Should Neville Stand or Sit in Defiance WAS Re: Snape Re: good ides bad idea?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 115734


> SSSusan:
> Well put, Laura--I like that "wrong sides of the same side."  
> 
> My question would be, how would the students in DA take having 
Snape 
> as their advisor?  I agree with all the other points you've made --
  
> DD trusts him, he's in the Order, and he also presumably knows the 
> Dark Arts well.  But these kids have had a really good time with 
> Harry as their leader.  I wonder how they would react if ol' 
Severus 
> showed up to take charge?  (Would be an interesting scene to read, 
> wouldn't it?)
> 


Alla:

I really and sincerely hope that such thing will NEVER happen. :) 
Ever. As Dzeytoun said, Dumbledore caused enough problems for Harry 
with his idealistic hope that Harry and Snape could ever get along.

Although it did made a great read, I admit.

Harry accomplished far more with DA members than Snape accomplished 
with Gryffs in his potions class. Hmmm, I wonder if Harry is a 
better teacher at 15 than Snape is at 36. Again, I am hoping that 
this will not be ruined and if Dumbledore decides that DA members 
indeed need to be inloved in the more complicated studies, someone 
else will be made their advisor. I so want to say Lupin :o). Maybe 
Dumbledore will make it unofficial position, so Remus can be at 
Hogwarts again?