Snape vs. MWPP

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 115739


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Tammy" <elsyee_h at y...> wrote:

snip.

>> You can't judge Snape's behaviour in POA yet, as we still don't 
fully
> know the full details of their past relationship, or all the bad 
blood
> between them. 
> 


Alla:

Just a quick comment. You are saying that we cannot judge Snape's 
behaviour in PoA yet, because we don't know the full amount of bad 
blood between them and Marauders. I MAY be inclined to agree with 
you, if you tell me that you agree that we cannot judge James and 
Sirius baehaviour in pensieve scene yet, because we don't know the 
full amount of the bad blood between them and Snape yet and it is 
impossible to judge seven year relationship based on ONE scene.

Personally, as I said a few times earlier, I have a very strong 
belief that we will find out about HUGE amount of bad blood either 
between James and Snape or Sirius and Snape or their families, BUT 
just as I think that Pensieve scene is despicable on its own, no 
back story needed, I also think that Snape's behaviour in PoA is 
quite despicable on its own.