Sorting Hat - Slytherin Truth
finwitch
finwitch at yahoo.com
Mon Oct 18 08:42:53 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 115837
Steve wrote: So, Slytherin's position could have been pretty radical
and agressive
> without being irrational or racist. In addition, Slytherin's
position,
> if it was as I speculate, as you can see, could very easily be
twisted
> to suit people like Voldemort and the purebloods.
>
> If you catch my drift.
>
Finwitch:
Brilliant post! I agree - Slytherin surely could have done that. And
many Slytherin-raised wizards, being wizard-born with no knowledge of
Muggles today, might *still* share that view.
Anyway, I'd say that wizards then had a good idea to hide. That way,
Muggles who stopped believing in magic, developed (from memories
about the magic?) technology & electricity - (or were those made by
some undercover-wizards?) - and quite possibly, via entertainment
books etc. come to the conclusion that magic in itself is not a bad
thing to be rid of by killing anyone different...
However, even if all Muggles (most today, I think, but we know all
too well about some fanatics who don't) would be ready to find out
about wizards and accept it without attempting to burn everyone - the
trouble is in getting the wizards agree! (Slytherin most likely
thought NEVER - while the others disagreed, and kept contact via
Muggle-borns, who had MORE to fear than the wizards...)
Finwitch
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive