Question to the psys.

evita2fr Snarryfan at aol.com
Wed Oct 20 22:19:29 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 116073



I'm not really want to restart the Snape/abuse thread, but I wanted 
to know something.

I think Snape has a limit in his sadist streak. I love him but, yes, 
he's a sadist still learning how life work, or waiting Voldie's death 
to begin.

I think (only based on the two times he stop someone to hurt Neville 
in OOTP) that he'll never accept that someone physically hurt a 
child. And that he doesn't consider verbal abuse like abuse, rather 
like a 'stop whining, I lived the same stuff and I'm still alive' 
stuff.

Jo said that Snape could be worse that what we saw with the 'good' 
impulse (now, how the DADA job could do that...) and well, I think he 
could have do worse in the pensieve scene.

Is someone else had the feeling that Snape shouted to Harry to go out 
as far as possible to prevent himself to do more ill ? That he 
thought "I'll kill hi...stop, POTTER. OUT. NOW!!!"

Anyway, my question (which had probably nothing to do with my post) 
is :

Could one hate something in a person without realizing that one do it 
too?

Could Snape doesn't tolerate physical abuse without realizing that 
he's border or over the line himself?

Christelle, who want to know what could happen to the poor guy who 
would try to hurt one Snape's student. Yeah, I'm thinking a Slytherin.











More information about the HPforGrownups archive