CHAPTER DISCUSSION: Chapter 29, Career Advice

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 116176


:
> > Carol responds:
Since Draco is present, it seems likely that he's the 
culprit, "accidentally" knocking over Harry's potion while 
> > handing in his own. Snape maintains his usual favor-the-
Slytherins,
> > antagonize-Harry stance, with his snide little remark and the 
> > supposed zero. 

Alla:

Carol, truly and honestly, I am not being sarcastic, but , in your 
opinion,is Snape EVER wrong in his treatment of Harry or could you 
justify every incident which happened between these two?

Maybe you could admit once that he is an unprofessional git, or he 
is always a shining example of how teacher should behave? :o)


I love Sirius dearly, but I can tell you so many times, when he was 
wrong, wrong, wrong...

Could you do the same or is Snape always right, right, right?

(Not that I am forcing you, of course. Maybe what seems so obvious 
to me is looking as direct opposite to you)

Flask is on Snape's desk and even though it could be a possibility 
that Draco touched it, it does not look very likely to me. Besides, 
it seems so IC for Snape to do so.


Here I was thinking how to better phrase my reply and Nora did it 
much better as usual. :o) So, to continue reading my thoughts, I can 
safely refer you to her post. :o)