smashing flasks Re: CHAPTER DISCUSSION: Chapter 29, Career Advice

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 116263


> Potioncat:
> And this is part of the reason I don't think Snape broke it.  I 
> think if he were going to break it (and he is that mean) he would 
> have broken it in front of Harry for the extra bit of "Gotcha!"



Alla:


Oh, Potioncat, I love you. :o) I feel VERY comfortable disagreeing 
with you, because you make minor concessions ,while defending Snape 
overall and it makes me want to concede more. 


For example here even though you don't think that Snape broke the 
flask, you concede that he IS mean enough to do it.


I definitely see you point - that Snape could have tried to 
humiliate Harry in MORE open way, not in more hidden way. That I can 
agree with.


Still think Snape did it, though. :)