Snape's stalling
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sun Oct 24 16:17:47 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 116348
>
> Potioncat:
> Well, I'll bet we differ on what we think he did! ;-)
> Just to show you how open my mind is, in fact it's pretty much a
> leaky cauldron most of the time, I'll toss this out: DD says twice
> that Snape reported immediately. How does he know that?
Alla:
Heee! I just pictured Potioncat's mind as Leaky Cauldron. :o)
Actually, we don't necessarily differ on this one. You see, I am
HAPPY when Snape does the right thing. I WANT to believe the best of
him. The thing is - he dissapoints me oh so often. :o)
If Dumbledore said to Harry : "Professor Snape WENT to forest to
search for you". I would not question it for a minute.
Just as you see ambiguity in the smashed flask scene, I think that
the word INTENDED used here for a reason.
What Dumbledore's quote are you talking about? I remember this
one "he informed the Order as soon as possible about what you had
just said" - OOP, p.833
But yes, I remember seeing "immediately" in the other context, I
just cannot find it right now.
I guess this refers to still unknown to us the means of
communications between Members of OOP
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive