Snape's stalling
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Sun Oct 24 20:20:48 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 116368
Pippin:
> Of course he did...but I thought you would say that he did it
> because he wanted Harry to be scared and was indifferent to his
> safety. Neri's argument, IIRC, was that Snape delayed
> searching the forest for Harry because he didn't really care what
> happened to him, and I thought you were supporting it.
Alla:
I think we got confused again, Pippin. I do support Neri's argument
and I thought that you brought up "snake' as example of Snape
helping Harry, even if not right away.
I was asking what to help with, if Snape did it from the beginning?
I just don't think that it was a good example fo Snape HELPING Harry.
Pippin:
> I think Snape wanted to find out if Harry was a parselmouth and
> he also wanted to cause Harry some grief over throwing the
> firework into Goyle's potion and stealing the supplies (which he
> would have discovered by then.)
Alla:
Cause Harry some grief? Absolutely. I don't call Snape sadist for no
reason, after all. :)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive