When did Fudge come to power?
imamommy at sbcglobal.net
imamommy at sbcglobal.net
Thu Oct 28 03:07:41 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 116598
imamommy:
I found some seeming inconsistencies with the timing of when Fudge
became Minister of Magic.
When the trio meets Sirius in Hogsmeade (GoF, Schol. p.529-30), he is
talking about what happened with Crouch Sr, shortly after his "son"
died in Azkaban:
"So old Crouch lost it all, just when he thought he had it made,"
Snip
"So Cornelius Fudge got the top job, and Crouch was shunted
sideways into the Department of International Magical Cooperation."
Then in OoP, this reference doesn't have any particular time frame
attached, but here it is (Oop, Schol. p.93-4, Arthur Weasley
speaking):
"Of course he doesn't," said Mr. Weasley "He's <Dumbledore>
never wanted the Minister's job, even though a lot of people wanted
him to take it when Millicent Bagnold retired. Fudge came to power
instead, but he's never quite forgotten how much popular support
Dumbledore had, even though Dumbledore never applied for the job."
"Deep, down, Fudge knows Dumbledore's much cleverer than he is, a
much more powerful wizard, and in the early days of his ministry he
was forever asking Dumbledore for help and advice," said Lupin.
Then later, as reported in the Quibbler (Oop, Schol. p.192):
Cornelius Fudge, the Minister of Magic, denied that he had any plans
to thake over the running of the Wizarding Bank, Gringotts, when he
was elected Minister of Magic five years ago.
Hmm. If the attack on the Potter's was Halloween 1981, and the attack
on the Longbottoms was later that year or early 1982, then the trial
may have been a few months later, the person believed to be Barty
Crouch, Jr. probably died in 1983 or '84. "Five years ago" from the
beginning of OoP would be 1990, or a year before Harry started at
Hogwarts. But my first example seems to indicate that the transfer
of power occured not long after the death in Azkaban.
Any thoughts?
imamommy
Who's well aware that the Quibbler can hardly be counted on for facts
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive