Dirty Harry / 'Good' Harry (WAS: The intended murder of Pettigrew and

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 116762



> Del replies :
> Stealing is not only against the school rules, but also against the
> law. This was no mere "formal breaking of the rules".


Alla:

I can analogise it a bit with DA army. I can only cheer them up for 
such "breaking of the law"

Del:
 
> I know they had good intentions, but this in itself does not excuse
> the theft. Moreover, if good intentions are all that matter, then I
> don't see what the big fuss is with Harry having to kill or be 
killed.
> Harry has a good intention in wanting to rid the world of LV and
> preserving his own life, so why should the idea of killing LV 
bother
> Harry ?


Alla:


Yes, if Harry is the kid who often breaks the rules, lies, cheats 
and steals without any good purpose,  that is the good question. Why 
the idea of killing his worst enemy should bother  him that much?


I'd say becuase he is not that bad in the first place and does not 
want to kill even his worst enemy.