Dirty Harry / 'Good' Harry (WAS: The intended murder of Pettigrew and

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 116767



Pippin:

> But stealing from your worst enemy is okay? Well, maybe so, but 
> I doubt Snape views it that way, or Rowling for that matter. <g>. 
In 
> fact,  I think this throws some light on the infamous tooth 
remark. 
> Harry's firecracker in CoS splashed Swelling Solution over half  
> the class. Harry got paid back by the snake, but I think in 
Snape's 
> long, long memory for injuries, Hermione finally got what was 
> coming to her.
> 



Alla:

Oh, no, no, Pippin, of course it is not OK under ordinary 
circumstances, but I submit that circumstances were far from 
ordinary there. :)

I always respected you, but after this post my respect increased 
many times. I love how you like Snape, without having any illusions 
about his behaviour as to kids.

It is entirely possible that Snape's remark about Hermione's teeth 
was payback for what happened two years ago. 

Can I just question Snape's emotional maturity for doing that?