Harry, Hermione, Sirius, and the Dream

[delwynmarch]

No: HPFGUIDX 116790


meriaugust wrote:
"While I agree that Hermione was right to look at Sirius' motives with
a bit of sketpicism, she was wrong to bring up the "saving people
thing" and she was wrong to try and convince Harry that he was
dreaming when  there was no evidence that he was. After all his last
vision had been dead right. "

Del replies :
Wrong ?? I just don't get it. She was *right* all along !! LV DID use
Harry's saving-people thing to lure him into the MoM, and Harry's
dream WAS a fake (and there *was* evidence : as I said in my previous
post, it was immediately obvious to me that this dream couldn't be
true, I can explain why if you want).

Del