Stopper in Death (WAS: Help!)
dungrollin
spotthedungbeetle at hotmail.com
Thu Sep 2 14:49:00 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 111913
Bookworm:
> It is such a great speech there has to be something more to it.
> Maybe Snape could get Remus or Hermione to persuade Harry to
> drink it? They are less distrusting of Snape. Or Dumbledore, if
> he is still around by then?
DuffyPoo:
> I have thought that Snape made one of his stopper death potions
> for LV while he was an active DE which turned, or helped turn,
> LV into Vapormort when he AK'd HP. What HP may need to find out,
> with Snape's help, is the exact potion used and the antidote for
> the formula.
Now Dungrollin:
I'm sitting here with my copy of Chambers English Dictionary,
worried, because I always interpreted this passage differently...
I'll just quote some bits from the entry for 'stop' (it's quite
long, so I won't put it all in).
Stop (vt):
to cause to cease, to bring to a standstill; to hinder or prevent
the passage of ; to prevent (etc etc etc)...
Stopper (n): a person who stops; that which stops; a plug; a plug
(usu glass) for a bottle; a short rope for making something fast
(naut). (- vt): to close or secure with a stopper.
I understood 'even stopper death' to mean put death in a bottle with
a stopper, i.e. 'even bottle death'.
I'm not going to start a discussion on how JKR uses language
(although throughout OotP I was getting a little sick of people
saying things 'breathlessly') but if I had wanted to imply 'even
prevent death' I'd have used different words, or just said 'even
stop death'.
Did anyone else understand it in this way, or am I just being weird?
Cheers,
Dungrollin.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive