The Beetle At Bay

[kmcbears1]

No: HPFGUIDX 111962

Yb wrote:
> I am not completely forgiving Hermione. She is rather manipulative 
> in this situation, and she's being a bit Machiavellian (ends 
justify 
> the means), and her behavior at the end of GoF (she keeps the poor 
> woman in a far until London, and she's pleased with herself), but 
> she has a good idea: stop Rita from writing lies, get the whole 
> story out correctly. She just uses the wrong methodology in putting 
> these ideas through.
> 
>From Karen:

Maybe she used the wrong methodology because she is 14 in GoF and 15 
in OotP,.

OotP Chapter 29:
"Then Lupin said quietly, 'I wouldn't like you to judge your father 
on what you saw there, Harry.  He was only fifteen ---.'"

Let's not be too harsh on Herminone she is only 14/15.

- Karen