Snape and DADA

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 112152

Magda:
> All this talk about love and choices will strike Snape as
> just so much wussery about emotions that can only make a wizard 
> weak, not strong. 


SSSusan:
"So much wussery"--what a great word! ;-)


Magda:
> Lately though I've been wondering about something: wouldn't it be a
> total kick if Harry has to time-turner 25 years into the past 
> because it's actually Harry and not James who pulls Snape out of 
> the tunnel and saves him from a werewolf?  Because Snape is needed 
> in the future for some potions work or something?


SSSusan:
I have *such* a hard time w/ time-turning, that I hesitate to even 
ask this, but....  Is it the general consensus that a person can TT 
to a moment *before* he was even born **and then perform some action 
which changes events**?  Not like in PoA, when H/H simply time-turn 
to a point w/in the same day?  Could Harry go back 25 years, to when 
he was "minus-10"??

Siriusly Snapey Susan