Lily, James and Azkaban.

womanofdunedain womanofdunedain at yahoo.com
Sun Sep 5 21:54:01 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 112173

Neha <girl_next_door704 at y...> wrote:
> In Book Five, Aunt Petunia says she knows of the Dementors 
> and about the wizards' prison Azkaban because she had once heard 
> James Potter talking about it with Lily. How is this possible if, 
> according to Book Four, the dementors joined the Ministry's side 
> after Voldemort's regime ceased, and that this happened after the 
> death of James and Lily Potter?   
                                                              

Couldn't they just have been discussing the prison in general? As 
in, they had received news about some suspected Death Eater who had 
been arrested, or any doubts that they might have had about the 
Dementors?

"womanofdunedain" 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive