"Slytherin" Hermione?

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Thu Sep 9 12:30:37 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 112479

Valky: 
> 4 The teachers see precisely the same points I do and hence do not 
> show open disapproval of Hermiones hex. Frankly it is good for the 
> bigger picture of the WW if the students realise Hermione is a 
> formidable foe.
>

Potioncat:
Do we have canon that says that Pomfrey didn't have the information 
she needed to remove the hex? Or canon that says she chose not to 
remove it?  I know, I know, she can re-grow bones, but she can't 
cure the common cold. (Pepper-up Potion sounds worse than the cold 
to me.)

"Yes, dear, a powerful hex.  Use this ointment for 8 weeks and it 
should clear up."

I can believe that Hermione wasn't punished (think werewolf) but I 
doubt the adults wouldn't have done something to help the girl.  

Along that line, do we know that Hermione didn't tell Pomfrey about 
the polyjuice mixup?





More information about the HPforGrownups archive