Book Two Discoveries - Collapsed tunnel

[Geoff Bannister]

No: HPFGUIDX 112604

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "kmcbears1" <karen at d...> wrote:

Karen:
> This may have been discused but I think it will play an important 
> part in the "attack on Hogwarts".
> 
> In CoS, Lockhart's failed memory charm collapses the ceiling of the 
> tunnel to the chamber of secrets.
> 
> In POA, George and Fred tell Harry that one of the secret passages 
to 
> Hogsmead was good until last year when it collapsed.
> 
> IMO these are the same or connecting tunnel and Voldemort and the 
DEs 
> will use them to invade Hogwarts.

Geoff:
I reproduce below the whole of message 90496 which tackles this 
problem:

================================================================
90496  From:  "Geoff Bannister" <gbannister10 at a...> 
Date:  Sun Feb 8, 2004  10:03 pm
Subject:  Re: Entering the Chamber

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Susan Miller" 
<constancevigilance at y...> wrote:

Constance Vigilance:
> I think this
> fact was demonstrated when Ron's wand malfunction in the Chamber
> tunnel FAR below Hogwarts was able to cause a cave-in and block the
> roomy passageway way up on the 4th floor. This is the secret
> passageway that the twins and Sirius mention. I think this is good
> evidence that at least those two passageways are related. I think
> most or all of them are related - and many of them lead out.

Geoff:
I must be being a bit thick but where did that idea come from?

According to canon, Fred speaking....

"'Don't bother with the one behind the mirror on the fourth floor. We
used it until last winter but it's caved in - completely blocked.'"

(POA "The Marauder's Map" p.144 UK edition)

This is in the November of 1993. So the cave-in was in the winter of
1992. but Harry's confrontation with the basilisk was in the summer
of '93 at the end of his second year.

"Ten minutes into the class, Professor McGonagall told them that
their exams would start on the first of June, one week from today."

(COS "The Chamber of Secrets" p.210 UK edition)

And Ginny was taken into the chamber three days before this date
(i.e. 29th May).

"Three days before their first exam, Professor McGonagall made
another announcement at breakfast."

(p.211 same chapter)
====================================================================

Geoff
See my views of Exmoor and the 
heritage West Somerset Railway at:
http://www.aspectsofexmoor.com