Alice Longbottom and the Potters

[littleleahstill]

No: HPFGUIDX 112733

 Karen writes:
>
> Neville is a full-blood so Alice Evans doesn't work. But I really
> like the idea of Alice Potter. I think this weaves very well in
the tapestry of JKRs writing.


Tonks:

>The Potters died a least a week or so before the Longbottoms ended
>up in St. Mungo's. Harry was taken to Petunia's house within 24
>hours of the death of Lily and James. Therefore if Alice was a
>Potter, Harry would have had some other blood relative that he could
>have gone with besides Petunia. But Petunia was the only one left.
>So the Alice Potter idea is out too.


Leah:

Harry has to be in the place where 'his mother's blood dwells', so if 
Alice is a Potter not an Evans, she would not have any of Lily's 
blood and  would not have been any use to him.