Three Defiances and Uncle Algie
frugalarugala
frugalarugala at yahoo.com
Mon Sep 13 20:27:12 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 112855
Frugalarugala (then):
> > Then there's Great Uncle Algie, AKA the gloved balcony dangler
> > of the WW. <snip>
>
> Carol:
> I don't remember any gloves in the anecdote about Neville being
> dropped, and I don't see anything sinister in Trevor.
Frugalarugala:
Carol, it was a Michael Jackson reference... Though actually IIRC
Neville was like eight at the time, rather than a baby.
Carol:
> Clearly, you see things differently. Can you explain why you think
> that Trevor "proves" (indicates?) that Algie is evil?
Frugalarugala:
Although I really think that Uncle Algie might have been trying to
prune the family tree, if Neville didn't have magic, "Trevor proving
it" was a joke. There was a thread going at the time I posted this,
speculating that Trevor might be yet another animagi, because he
keeps disappearing on Neville.
Actually, I've just always been bugged by the bits with Trevor. I
hope he has some importance in the whole storyline other than giving
Neville something to panic over, 'cause I like Neville when he's not
worrying over that toad, but I suspect his sole purpose is to show
Neville's worrywart, panicky side.
But even though I was being facetious, but I do think Uncle Algie
might have been pruning. I mean, what if Neville HAD been a squib?
He said he nearly drowned, and he's a wizard, if he had been a squib
would he have been a goner? Squibs presumably aren't more tough than
wizards.
Oh, and as far as the Mimbulus Mimbletonia goes, yeah Neville likes
it--but who the hell gives plants that sprays stinkiness as birthday
presents?! (Actually, I can't even type that without laughing! FTD
has nothing on Uncle Algie!) Neville likes it, I know.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive