Snape in the Shrieking Shack (was re:time-turning)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 112876

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "totorivers" wrote:

>   I do think there are some reasons.... Snape tries to get Harry 
> *expelled* on many occasions, and at his level it would mean out 
of 
> the wizarding world. And he does *not* fake that. Plus, as you 
said 
> yourself, he doesn't only target Harry but all Gryffindors, and 
> favours Slytherin. This has nothing to do with being *fair* or 
> *moral*. Maybe Snape is lying to himself though, but I think he 
> just continues his grudge against the Gryffindors and his belief 
that 
> anything Slytherin do it's because they are martyrised (yeah 
right) 
> and nothing based on proof.


Alla:

Well, I 'll grant you that Snape has a grudge against Harry and no, 
I don't think it comes anywhere close to fair treatment, but you 
have to give me the better examples, really, than Snape's threats to 
expel him.

Have you ever treated those seriously? Snape rants and raves in 
front of Dumbledore when for example Harry and Ron flied to school 
in Ford Angula In CoS.

Does Dumbledore pay any attentions to Snape hysterics? Nope. He lets 
McGonagall to deal with boys right away and I think it is a pretty 
safe bet to assume right away that Minerva is not going to expel 
them.