Why don't Ron and Ginny know? (WAS Gum Wrappers)
littleleahstill
cmjohnstone at hotmail.com
Tue Sep 14 20:41:34 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 112947
Following through on the gum wrappers thread, I suddenly wondered why
it was that Ron and Ginny were apparently as surprised as Hermione to
learn that Alice and Frank were in the closed ward?
Coming from the Dursleys, Harry could not be expected to know what
happened to the Longbottoms until he sees it in the pensieve, and the
same goes for muggle born Hermione. But Dumbledore tells Harry that
there was an outcry in the wizarding world when the Longbottoms were
attacked, 'a wave of fury', so all wizarding families must know what
happened. Dumbledore himself doesn't seem to have ordered secrecy as
a protection for Neville- he appears genuinely surprised to hear that
Neville has not explained things to Harry, and it is only the
realisation that Neville does not want the matter widely known that
makes DD enjoin Harry to keep it quiet. In fact, the sort of pathetic
individual who could make bullying capital out of insanity ie Draco
Malfoy, appears to have a fair idea already.
You would have thought that Ron or Seamus or other pure blood kids
would have mentioned at home that Neville was in their class - he is
quite a distinctive character. We must assume that their parents
know what happened to Neville's parents, so why does no one explain?
Is this silence (as I suspect)merely a literary device to develop
Neville as a character? Sympathy from other parents keeping them
quiet is possible, but would they all react the same way? Or
something else?
Leah
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive