Old Question (probably already answered) about Black and wands

macfotuk at yahoo.com macfotuk at yahoo.com
Tue Sep 14 23:48:25 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 112963

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" 
<justcarol67 at y...> wrote:
> DuffyPoo wrote:
> > 3) The wand Sirius uses in the DoM is one from the Black family 
home
> that belonged to either his Mother or Father or Regulus.  
> > 
> > I think Sirius probably had his wand with him when he was 
captured.
>  It would have been broken or at the very least taken from him.  He
> was going after Pettigrew, after all, and while I wouldn't put it 
past
> Sirius to kill Wormtail with his bare hands, it would have been
> quicker with a wand. ;-)
> 
> 
> Carol responds:
> While I agree that Sirius's wand must have been taken from him and
> broken after he ostensibly murdered Peter and the Muggles (why, why
> didn't they do Priori Incantatem on it?)

An interesting point Carol. However, since Fudge was there and he 
has a history of NEVER asking the right questions, in fact, 
completely the opposite (so that I've always felt ESE!Fudge or 
Imperio'd!Fudge have to be the case), it doesn't surprise me at all. 
What I've never really seen any discussion on is why Sirius is 
laughing madly when arrested. This, presumably, meant that he was 
taken to be mad and carted off as quickly as possible and without 
too many probing questions asked.

Are there any theories out there I haven't seen about why Sirius 
laughed? It certainly seems to have been what damned him, in the 
mind'seye of the WW, to all those years in Azkhaban (see Ernie Prang 
and Stan Shunpike's convo on the Knight Bus). 

Could Pettigrew have hexed Sirius just before blasting a hole into 
the sewer by which he escaped as scabbers? (I don't recall a mad 
laughter spell), but there is a mad/uncontrollable dancing 
(tarantallegra) spell after all.  





More information about the HPforGrownups archive