The Sneak Mark (was "Slytherin" Hermione?)

totorivers tombadgerlock at freesurf.fr
Tue Sep 14 19:50:53 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 112974

Pippin:
> But to someone who believed that the dementors were under 
> ministry control, and who didn't realize how much magic it would 
> take to actually fight them, being part of "Dumbledore's Army" 
> and training to use the patronus spell would look pretty bad, 
> especially after the Azkaban break out. It'd be like if your 
> self-defense group started training with armor-piercing bullets.
> You'd wonder if someone wasn't planning to fight cops.


  Except, once again, that it is known that Dementor don't obey that 
well, as Marietta has seen during the Quidditch match in 3rd year. 
Plus, a patronus doesn't kill dementors, just drives them away.... 
Self defence, my friend... Don't try to put values to Marietta just 
for your dislike of Hermione please, Hermione has her faults, but 
what Marietta did was betrayal both of Harry and her friend... And 
the risk of expulsion to them, just for a chance of advancement for 
her mother. She was greedy. Of course, if greediness is a value for 
you...

Toto






More information about the HPforGrownups archive