Sirius, Snape, and befuddlement draughts.

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 112984

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "arienastera" wrote:
>> So, like I said, I don't know if this has already been discussed, 
> but I wasn't there, so humor me... :)
> 
> Could Snape have given Sirius a potion to make him more reckless 
> than normal?  I know anyone would get bored cooped up that long, 
but 
> surely even he knows when to draw the line?  JKR seems to 
emphasize 
> that Potions Text bit, so maybe we're supposed to look at it more 
> than just "Harry's tired, he's allowed to be distracted this late".
> 
> We all know that Snape tried his darndest to get Sirius in POA, so 
> whats stopping him now that he knows where Sirius is.  Even if 
Snape 
> knows he's innocent, he still hates him with a fiery passion.
> 


Alla:

Hi, yep, I think it was discussed, but what stops us from doing it 
again? :o)

I think more or less general consensus was that Kreacher MAY have 
slipped the Potion to Sirius, although even that is not clear yet.

I am hoping that Snape did not do it, because that would mean that 
he is really partially to blame for Sirius' death and I don't want 
to think that Snape revenge can go THAT FAR.

Although, you never know with JKR, of course. :)