Tale of Two Wands - Fawkes as Supplier - When Created?

[gelite67]

No: HPFGUIDX 112986


> Finwitch wrote:
> 
> I don't know if it <i>matters</i> whether the tail-feathers given at
> the same time or not! The important thing is that they're both 
Fawkes'
> feathers, thus creating the Priori Incantatem-effect, as well as
> giving Harry an advantage, being that Fawkes is Harry's friend, as
> well as Dumbledore's pet.
> 

But I think it also goes to what DD knew and when.  Of course, we 
KNOW he knows a lot that JKR has yet to reveal.

Finwitch also wrote:
> 
> Well, Ollivander says that Fawkes *gave* the feathers, whereas he
> mentions having pulled the unicorn hair out, not about the unicorn
> *giving* it.
> 
> 
Angie reples:

Good point.  But voluntary or not, I think if DD wanted a tail 
feather, Fawkes would give it.

> Fonwitch wrote: I hope Book Six tells us whether
> Neville's wand has phoenix feather as a core!
> 
>Angie replies:

Well, Neville had his father's wand, but it got broken in OOP, so he 
will need a new wand in Book Six.  I know I'll be watching to see if 
he "core" is identified.