Weak and Evil!Fudge and the missing wands

huntergreen_3 patientx3 at aol.com
Wed Sep 15 23:24:37 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 113080

HunterGreen previously:
>>And it wasn't one of those hit wizards or an auror (am I right
in assuming Fudge wasn't an auror?), it was *Fudge* who was
first on the scene. Alone, no less. There quick enough that Sirius
hadn't left yet (which had to be fairly quick, I can't see why Sirius
would hang around there. <<

SSSusan:
> Just one little nitpick, HunterGreen. Fudge *wasn't* alone. He
> was "one of the first" to arrive on the scene.

HunterGreen:
You're right, that's what happens when I go from memory. The 
word 'the' didn't appear in the version in my head. Thank you for 
pointing that out SSSusan.

Pippin wrote:
>>Fudge was in the department of magical catastrophes, so he
had a legitimate reason for being there. I agree that the
department must have been tipped off, but that doesn't mean
that Fudge did it.<<

HunterGreen:
Indeed he was, which would have made him a good person for Wormtail 
to go to if he needed help disappearing (and framing Sirius). 
However, you are correct that it didn't have to be Fudge that was 
helping Wormtail, and that same person could have tipped off the 
Ministry.

Pippin:
>>who doesn't believe Fudge would say he had nightmares about
the Muggle bodies if he wanted Voldemort in power<<

HunterGreen:
Well, he doesn't specifically say 'nightmares' but that he 'still 
dreams about it sometimes', which would make sense. Evil or not, its 
not something anyone could easily forget.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive