Lupin and Boggart+Legilimency

pippin_999 foxmoth at qnet.com
Thu Sep 16 00:32:39 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 113088

> > Pippin:
> > If Lupin was not really asleep in the train compartment, he 
already knew that Sirius was coming  to Hogwarts. But it is 
interesting that soon after the episode you quote, Sirius is 
spotted in the stands by Harry, and possibly by 
transformed!Lupin as well. Of course the dementors just happen 
to pick that moment for a light snack. <<<

> mhbobbin writes:
> 
> Pippin, you are usually so correct that I pause (or is that paws) 
> before mentioning the vision of Sirius/Padfoot in the stands in 
the  wonderfully named Chapter "Grim Defeat" of PoA, is during 
Lupin's  time of the month.  <

So it is indeed. But you underestimate the cunning of ESE!Lupin. 
He was indeed transformed, but thanks to the potion  he had a 
human mind and, as we learn in OOP,  a convenient view of the 
Quidditch pitch from the DADA office. It's interesting that despite 
people summoning dementors hither and yon through the last 
three books, we have no idea how it's done. If it's a mind trick, 
then  transformed Lupin could do it, provided he's had his potion.

It's interesting that the other time dementors invade the grounds 
in PoA, Lupin is also transformed.  Of course he's supposed to 
have forgotten to take his potion then, but Snape's been wrong 
before.

Pippin






More information about the HPforGrownups archive