[HPforGrownups] Sirius, Snape, and befuddlement draughts.

[annegirl11 at juno.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 113127

ArienAstera, hi, nice to meet you.

She said:
> Could Snape have given Sirius a potion to make him more reckless 
> than normal?  I know anyone would get bored cooped up that long, but 
> surely even he knows when to draw the line?  

Aura now:
Ooo, I like this idea. That passage did seem to stick out at me, that the
text was somehow relevant. Snape, knowing when to draw the line? Oh
*hell* no. (Well, that's not entirly true, he knows when not to endanger
the Order, but he can be damn nasty when it comes to revenge,
specifically against Sirius.) Make Sirius bounce off the walls and feel
even worse about his confinement -- Snape even taunted Sirius about being
cooped up and unable to do any work for the Order. What would Snape's
motivation be, though? Just revenge? I don't see him actually trying to
get Sirius killed. My immediate thought involved going to a very fun
slashy place with Sirius, Remus, and/or Snape. :) 

Alla said:
>I am hoping that Snape did not do it, because that would mean that 
>he is really partially to blame for Sirius' death and I don't want 
>to think that Snape revenge can go THAT FAR.

Me again:
Even if Snape did give Sirius the potion, I agree that he wouldn't have
expected it to lead to Sirius' death; my whole premise of explaing
Snape's moments of heroism is "Snape's a bastard, but not a murderer." If
Snape only meant to drive Sirius a little nuts (or drive him to either
Snape or Lupin's bed, as is my interpretation), the death was an
accident. Which is the only reason I hope Snape didn't give him the
potion, or at least not right before Sirius died; Snape has enough guilt
(and other issues) that's turning him into a twisted, angry jackass. Last
thing he -- and everyone around him -- needs is more fuel for the fire.

Carol said:
> who would not want to spend so much as a minute alone in the
> Black mansion

Not the real one, but wouldn't that make an awesome Halloween haunted
house? 

Aura

~*~
Well that's a horse of a different color.
Fanfic and original stuff at www.homepage-host.uni.cc/w/ofnone

________________________________________________________________
Get your name as your email address.
Includes spam protection, 1GB storage, no ads and more
Only $1.99/ month - visit http://www.mysite.com/name today!