Snape and Harry again.

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 113249


> > Magda (who would enjoy reading some good discussion of this issue
> > from the archives if she could get the damn yahoo search 
function to
> > work properly)


Nora: 
> I seem to have been unclear--I meant there simply that the scene 
was 
> difficult for ME to read.  It's very unpleasant--but I should hope 
my 
> comments have never lead anyone to be in doubt that such was the 
case 
> for myself.


Potioncat:
Magda (and anyone else) it might be fun to look at this scene 
objectively and pull in canon support to see what the heck was going 
on...but not from a good side--bad side point of view. Some "what 
ifs?" and "how abouts?"  Going from the point of view that most of 
the characters in the scene eventually become good guys.

Nora, I also found this incredibly hard to read.  I found it very 
upsetting.