QTTA: US vs UK and older US editions

Bex hubbarrk at rose-hulman.edu
Sat Sep 18 23:02:10 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 113326

Geoff wrote:
> > > Bit of a side issue here. Is there more than one edition 
> > > of "Quidditch through the ages"?
> > > My edition hasn't got the frontispiece which Kneasy and others 
> > > have mentioned.
> >  
Mandy:
> > There must be as I have a US (Scholastic) edition of QTTA 
purchased 
> > in 2001 and it does have the 'Property of Hogwars School 
Library' 
> > frontispiece.
> > 
> > Perhaps it is only the newer editions that are different?
> 
Geoff;
> Just to complicate the last two messages, I bought my edition 
through 
> Amazon last year on the Net here in the UK.
> 
> My edition is listed as Arthur A.Levine books, am imprint of 
> Scholastic Press on the title page. In miniscule print on the next 
> pag, it declares that it is first American edition February 2001.
> 
> No frontispiece bits and bobs.

Yb now:
That's a shame. I have the First Hardcover Boxed Set edition, 
September 2001, and it has the frontispiece, with a little note at 
the bottom from Irma Pince threatening consequences to anyone who 
mishandles the book.

I don't think it matters that much, since someone already pointed 
out a FLINT with Hermione and Harry's checkout dates. But it shows 
who has a bit of an interest in learning about Quidditch (nearly all 
of the Gryffindor Q Team checked it out). I think that was all the 
purpose the frontispiece was meant to serve, to give it a "library 
book" look.

~Yb





More information about the HPforGrownups archive