James and Snape. Was. Re: Snape and Harry again.

[evita2fr]

No: HPFGUIDX 113463


> > Pippin:
> > After the pensieve scene it no longer seems inconceivable to me  
> > that Snape honestly thought James and his friends might want 
> > him dead, and I can see him joining that Slytherin gang because 
> > he felt he needed protection from James and *his* gang,  and 
> > later joining the DE's because he felt he owed it to his friends. 
> > McGonagall keeps stressing that Gryffindors should never gang 
> > up on another person, and I can't think that JKR isn't going to 
> > show us why. But I could be wrong;-)
 
> Valky:
> How does the Pensieve scene imply that James and Sirius would kill 
> Snape?


I think that what Pippin means (and I'm sorry if I'm wrong) it's that 
if you take the Prank like a isolated 'incident', like we could do 
before OOTP, it was possible that it was an exceptional act of 
violence, and that Snape exaggerated, and saw a very bad and 
dangerous act of stupidy like a try to murderer him.

With the pensieve, and Lily's words, we know that it happened often, 
that Snape suffered (and probably give) more attacks than just the 
prank.

He could see this like a peak of the Marauder's goal, and so, 
honestly believe that they want his death, at least three of them 
(he had no reason to believe that it was only Sirius's idea).

Am I right, Pippin?

Christelle, who wonder where was Peter this night, and how Sirius 
though explain a corpse when Prongs, Wormtail and himself would 
rejoin Moony, like they do every months.