"Why didn't Dumbledore try to kill Voldemort...?"

harriet_lupin harriet_lupin at yahoo.com
Tue Sep 21 00:59:40 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 113485

JKR says that that is one of the two questions that people should ask 
but haven't asked.  Well, I feel the reason why people haven't asked 
it is because the answer is given to us in the Prophecy in Book 5...

JKR  tells us that only Harry can kill V and D knows it.  I feel that 
D is stalling when he stands up to V in the MoM, when he tells V that 
there are things "worse than death".  He can only defend Harry by 
putting things in the path of V's would-be death curse.  We all know 
that D cannot kill V.

Maybe what JKR is referring to pertains to the things that V did to 
himself to try and gain immortality.  I feel that Harry may be the 
only one who could penetrate this "wall" that may be surrounding V.

Now, I'm really babbling on....  Any thoughts?

Harriet







More information about the HPforGrownups archive