Source of LV's evil nature
gelite67
gelite67 at yahoo.com
Tue Sep 21 04:22:33 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 113494
---
> [Snip]
> Sarah wrote:
>
> I think we're missing some info on TR's mum. <snip>
> Also, the circumstances about her death seems weird to me. I think
> we were told that she died giving birth to TR. This doesn't seem to
> make sense considering all those wizard cures they have. <snip,
see below> Can child birth kill a wizard then?
>
> Angie replies:
Good point -- TR probably sucked the life force out of her! It seems
like most of the things that have been easily "cured" were relatively
minor: broken bones, bone replacements, blood loss, minor hexes.
Things like that. To me, the fact that child birth can kill a wizard
(or technically, I guess, a witch) is consistent with the fact that
wizards can't raise the dead - meaning their power over life and
death is limited. Like Muggle doctors, wizards can't cure
everything.
Sarah also wrote:
Hagrid was offended when he found that Harry believed that his
parents died in a car crash.
Angie replies:
True, but I think his offense was twofold: First, he was offended
that the Dursleys had lied to Harry and belittled James and Lily's
death. Second, as you seem to indicate, I believe it was a reference
to the fact that James and Lily were powerful wizards and that it
would have taken more than a mere car crash to kill them (which begs
the question of whether Muggle-type illnesses or accidents can kill
wizards in the first place). Thus, whether a an illness or accident
is fatal may depend on the power of the particular witch/wizard. We
don't know how strong a witch TR's mother was, although some may
assume she was strong and that is where he got some of his power.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive